Zum Inhalt springen

Advertising and media: should investment be mandated, or should the appetite to invest be rebuilt?

11/15/2026 Stephane 9 Min. Lesezeit

Advertising and media: should investment be mandated, or should the appetite to invest be rebuilt?

What if the media financing crisis also reveals a crisis in how their advertising value is perceived?

Faced with the concentration of digital investment around a handful of large platforms, the French government is considering requiring certain advertisers to allocate part of their digital advertising spend to political and general news publishers. The objective is legitimate: safeguarding pluralism and supporting publishers whose business models are under growing pressure.

But this response raises a deeper question. Can an advertising imbalance be durably corrected by mandating budget allocation, without addressing the reasons why advertisers today favour certain environments over others?

Because media are not necessarily lacking in strengths. They have content, audiences, trust relationships and editorial environments that brands continue to seek out. Their challenge is also to turn these qualities into economic value that is demonstrable enough to weigh in advertising trade-offs.

What if the real challenge were not only to redirect investment, but to rebuild the reasons to invest?

1. When regulation tries to correct a market imbalance

The French advertising-earmarking proposal starts from an observation that is hard to contest: digital advertising is heavily concentrated around a limited number of platforms, while the media that produce a significant share of professional and journalistic information struggle to capture a comparable share of investment.

According to the elements presented in the public debate, the envisaged scheme would apply to advertisers whose annual advertising spend exceeds one million euros. It would provide that a fraction of their digital investment be allocated to online political and general news publishers, at a rate set by decree and capped at 10%. This cap does not imply an immediate obligation to allocate 10% of all advertising budgets to the press. The scheme remains, at this stage, a legislative project whose terms and adoption are not yet settled.

The objective goes beyond advertising economics alone. Independent, diverse and accessible information is part of how democracy functions. Yet producing it requires significant human and editorial investment, in an environment where information distribution and attention capture are increasingly influenced by platforms and digital interfaces.

The question of timing also matters. Vincent Arvers, President of MediaSquare, points out that authorities often intervene several years after competitive advantages have taken root, when dominant positions are already entrenched. This observation highlights a structural difficulty: regulation enters a market whose equilibriums have sometimes been profoundly transformed before corrective measures can produce their effects.

But acknowledging the need for public intervention is not enough to demonstrate that any intervention will produce the intended results. A spending obligation can shift budgets. It does not guarantee where they come from, how effective they will be, or that beneficiary media will become more competitive on a lasting basis.

This is the whole ambiguity of the project: responding to a real economic emergency without necessarily solving the mechanisms that produced it.

2. Why do advertisers favour platforms?

To understand this concentration, advertiser decisions need to be looked at through something other than an opposition between legacy media and tech giants.

Digital platforms have progressively built integrated advertising environments. They enable audience targeting, rapid campaign activation, investment adjustments, access to granular data and — with methodological limitations — the ability to link advertising exposure to commercial outcomes.

This integration constitutes a considerable economic advantage. It reduces certain coordination costs, simplifies buying for many advertisers and provides indicators that can be used directly in their decision processes. It also strengthens dependence on proprietary environments, in which a single company can control a large share of distribution, data and measurement.

By comparison, traditional media long organised their offer around different logics: content quality, audience reach, editorial context, relationship with the public and valuation of ad space. These characteristics remain relevant, but on their own they do not always meet contemporary demands for comparison and investment justification.

It would nonetheless be misleading to portray all media as technologically outdated. Broadcast groups are developing their streaming platforms and targeting capabilities. Publishers are investing in first-party data, subscriptions, joint commercial offers and audience measurement. Some premium environments already offer sophisticated digital advertising solutions.

The problem is therefore not simply one of technological lag. It also lies in the ability of media to have their advantages recognised in a market whose buying criteria have profoundly changed.

An engaged audience, a credible editorial context or a lasting relationship with readers can create value for a brand. But how is that value assessed? How is it compared to other channels? And how does it enter budget allocation decisions?

The quality of a media environment can be a competitive advantage. One still has to be able to demonstrate its contribution to advertiser objectives.

3. Can a spending obligation recreate value?

This is where the debate becomes particularly interesting.

For supporters of advertising earmarking, public intervention could help rebalance the resources of a sector that is essential to pluralism. News publishers do not produce only advertising inventory: they perform a democratic function whose collective benefits exceed the revenue they are able to generate.

This argument deserves to be heard. Market mechanisms do not necessarily reward all the social benefits of independent information. It would therefore be reductive to judge any press-support policy solely by advertisers’ return on investment.

But the proposed mechanism raises another question: why should this responsibility fall primarily on companies’ advertising budgets?

Advertisers do not invest in media solely to fund them. They are looking for audiences, relevant environments, brand effects and — depending on their objectives — commercial results. A mandated spend does not automatically become an investment considered as performing.

There is also the risk of budget displacement rather than a rebalancing at the expense of dominant platforms. Nothing guarantees that amounts allocated to news publishers would come exclusively from spending previously placed with the large platforms. They could also come from the specialist press, broadcast media or other channels already subject to strong competition.

The scope of beneficiaries itself raises a question of pluralism. Political and general news publishers play an essential role, but specialist, professional, cultural and regional media, along with new editorial actors, also contribute to information diversity. A targeted mechanism can respond to a legitimate political priority while creating new differences in treatment between content producers.

Finally, indirect effects must be examined: administrative complexity, oversight costs, budget trade-offs, inventory price evolution or the maintenance of commissions levied by technology intermediaries. Part of the additional resources may not benefit journalism production directly.

You can require an advertiser to buy an ad space. You cannot require them to consider that space as a value creator.

This distinction does not necessarily condemn the project. It is simply a reminder that two different objectives are at stake: financing an activity of general interest, and rebuilding the commercial attractiveness of media.

The first can be a matter of public policy choice. The second requires a deeper transformation of the advertising value proposition.

4. Making investment attractive again: rebuilding the value of premium media

What if part of the answer lay in evolving how media present, commercialise and demonstrate their value?

Editorial quality, environment credibility and audience relationships are important assets. But they would gain from being more clearly linked to the concrete objectives of advertisers: attention, memorisation, consideration, trust, engagement and contribution to business outcomes.

That starts with making buying easier. More readable offers, pooled commercial schemes, comparable formats and better interoperability of measurement could reduce the coordination costs that today favour integrated platforms. It is not necessarily about imitating their model, but about removing the obstacles that make certain investments harder to plan, activate and evaluate.

The question of measurement is just as important. Premium media may offer environments that are favourable to advertising reception without this advantage automatically translating into better effectiveness. To establish that contribution, it must be possible to compare campaigns, isolate context effects and rely on methodologies credible enough to be accepted by advertisers, agencies and sales houses.

Advertising innovation also has a role to play. Interactive formats, formats combining advertising with verified consumer experiences, new approaches to attention measurement and incrementality evaluation methods open up interesting avenues. Their value, however, should not be assumed: it depends on their ability to produce results that are reproducible and significant enough to justify their cost.

This logic could help transform the relationship between media and advertisers. Rather than only asking for more investment in the name of content quality, media could strengthen their ability to demonstrate what their environments specifically bring to campaigns.

This does not mean every medium must become a performance platform, or that every piece of advertising creative can be reduced to a conversion indicator. Brand building, desirability and long-term effects are not measured like an immediate transaction. But the difficulty of measuring certain effects is no excuse for giving up on understanding them better.

A reconquest strategy therefore means defending the singularity of media while modernising the proofs of their value.

The press, broadcast media and other premium media do not necessarily need to become copies of the large platforms. They need to make their own advantages easier to buy, to compare and to value.

Conclusion — Supporting media is not enough. The reasons to invest in them must also be strengthened.

The debate over advertising earmarking reveals a deep tension between two legitimate imperatives: preserving the economic conditions of pluralism and respecting advertisers’ investment logic.

Public intervention can help support publishers weakened by market transformation. It can also be justified by democratic objectives that go beyond the immediate interests of businesses. But on its own it does not guarantee that media will durably regain a more significant place in advertising strategies.

Because the concentration of digital investment is not only the result of a regulatory imbalance. It also rests on advantages in distribution, data, technology integration and measurement that platforms have built over time.

The response cannot therefore be exclusively regulatory. It must also be economic, commercial and technological.

Premium media have qualities that advertisers continue to seek. Their challenge now is to better demonstrate how these qualities contribute to brand value, without giving up their editorial singularity.

Pluralism deserves to be supported. Advertising value deserves to be demonstrated.

And if the aim is to durably rebalance investment, the most important question may not only be what share of their budgets advertisers should be required to devote to media.

It is what will give them, tomorrow, more reasons to do so voluntarily.

Erhalten Sie AdTrust in Ihrem LinkedIn-Postfach

Redaktionelle Perspektiven zu Vertrauen, Beweis und der Zukunft der Werbung.

AdTrust-Newsletter abonnieren ->