Zum Inhalt springen

Advertising innovation has its own Messy Middle: who agrees to go first?

10/30/2026 Stephane 9 Min. Lesezeit

Advertising innovation has its own Messy Middle: who agrees to go first?

Innovation occupies a singular place in the advertising industry. Conferences celebrate it, agencies claim it, advertisers seek it, and sales houses see in it an opportunity to renew their value proposition. Yet between the interest shown in an idea and the decision to experiment with it, there is sometimes a considerable distance.

This paradox does not necessarily reflect a lack of boldness. Organisations must protect their investments, justify their choices and demonstrate the effectiveness of the initiatives they fund. But how do you evaluate an innovation that, precisely because it is new, does not yet have the references needed to reassure its first users?

This difficulty recalls a well-known marketing mechanism: the Messy Middle, that space of exploration and evaluation in which the consumer hesitates before making a decision. What if companies, too, went through their own Messy Middle when they consider adopting an innovation?

1. Innovation appeals. The first commitment is another story.

In advertising, innovation enjoys a paradoxical advantage: almost no one wants to appear hostile to change. Advertisers look for new levers of effectiveness, agencies for new approaches for their clients, and media for solutions capable of differentiating their inventory. Yet this shared interest does not always turn into concrete decisions.

An idea can elicit a favourable reaction during a presentation, be judged relevant by several stakeholders and even address a recognised market problem, without any player deciding to fund its first experiment. This gap deserves study. It is not enough to explain the inaction by the caution of decision-makers: an innovation may also be insufficiently mature, poorly positioned or difficult to integrate into existing processes.

Consider a fictional example, but one representative of advertising decision circuits. A TV sales house discovers a new format combining advertising creative and verified consumer reviews. The idea interests it, but it would like an advertiser to first express an intention to try it. The media agency, consulted in turn, recognises the potential of the format while asking for measured results before recommending it to its client. The advertiser, for its part, waits for its agency to validate the relevance of the investment and for the sales house to confirm the broadcasting conditions. Each advances legitimate arguments. Yet several months can pass without any decision being made.

This mechanism reveals a difficulty less visible than resistance to change: the fragmentation of responsibility. The sales house does not want to mobilise its inventory without commercial demand, the agency hesitates to recommend a format lacking references, and the advertiser does not want to fund alone an experiment whose benefits remain uncertain. No one necessarily rejects the innovation, but no one simultaneously holds the means, the mandate and the interest to organise its first test. The absence of a decision ends up substituting for a genuine evaluation.

The risk is no longer only that of an innovation that would fail. It is that of an innovation that would never really be evaluated.

2. The Messy Middle: when the need for proof delays the decision

In 2020, researchers Alistair Rennie and Jonny Protheroe, in a study published by Google, proposed the concept of the Messy Middle to describe the complexity of the purchase journey. Between the triggering of a need and the final decision, the consumer does not necessarily progress in a linear way. They alternate between exploration and evaluation, discover new possibilities, compare offers and seek information likely to reduce their uncertainty.

Consumer reviews, recommendations and credibility signals can intervene in this process. Their value lies not only in their ability to reassure: they bring information complementary to the promise made by the brand. A verified purchase experience does not guarantee that a product will suit everyone, but it can help inform a decision.

This reading leads us to re-examine the role of advertising. A message can create attention and desirability without being enough to dispel the questions that separate interest from purchase. Associating advertising creative with proof of consumer experience could help bring these two moments closer. It would still be necessary to measure this effect under comparable conditions, rather than assuming that a mechanism observed in e-commerce will automatically reproduce in a TV or BVoD campaign.

But the parallel becomes particularly interesting when we observe the decisions of companies themselves. Faced with an innovation, marketing managers may adopt comparable behaviours: multiplying exchanges, consulting their partners, comparing solutions, requesting additional guarantees and deferring their commitment. The more uncertainty remains, the more the evaluation risks generating new requests for information.

It is obviously not a matter of claiming that the consumer’s behavioural model applies scientifically, without adaptation, to the investment decisions of organisations. A company has budgetary, legal and operational constraints that cannot be reduced to cognitive biases. But the analogy reveals a common tension: in both cases, the search for proof aims to reduce uncertainty, without necessarily eliminating it.

The consumer looks for proof before buying. The advertiser looks for proof before experimenting. In both cases, the question becomes that of the level of uncertainty acceptable in order to decide.

3. Those innovations that had to build their own legitimacy

The history of advertising and media technologies shows that the adoption of an innovation does not depend solely on its initial relevance. It often requires the convergence of uses, standards, measurement methods and economic interests.

Viewability offers a particularly revealing illustration. For a long time, digital advertising was mainly sold on the basis of served impressions, without these guaranteeing a genuinely visible exposure. The question of visibility gradually imposed new measurement requirements. In 2014, the Media Rating Council’s lifting of its advisory against the transactional use of viewable impressions marked an important step. The adoption of this measure nevertheless remained gradual. In 2015, the IAB still described a transition period, with technical difficulties and measurement discrepancies between vendors. The challenge was not only to create an indicator: the various players had to agree to use it as a common reference.

The evolution of television measurement in the United Kingdom tells another story. BARB began publishing BVoD consumption data in 2015, before introducing multiscreen audience measurement in 2018, then gradually broadening the coverage of screens and uses. This transformation did not consist of replacing an old measure with a new one overnight. It required bringing together different technical environments and market conventions to build a more coherent view of audiovisual consumption.

The QR code is a third example, further from measurement but just as instructive. Invented in 1994 by DENSO, it first met concrete industrial needs. Its adoption in consumer uses then depended on the evolution of phones, applications and behaviours. The technology existed well before the conditions for its everyday use were widely met. Its journey is a reminder that an innovation can be relevant in one environment without being so immediately in all others.

These examples do not prove that every innovation will eventually prevail with enough patience. Many disappear, sometimes for good reasons. They show rather that an idea becomes a market practice only when its benefits can be understood, its constraints mastered and its results evaluated according to criteria acceptable to those who must adopt it.

The difficulty of the first commitment cannot therefore be separated from building trust in the method itself.

4. The first PoC: buying a performance or funding knowledge?

When a company experiments with an innovation, it should not necessarily seek to confirm a commercial promise. It should first seek to answer a question precise enough to justify the test. In the case of a new advertising format, this question could be simple: does adding verified consumer proof improve the credibility of the message, its memorisation, engagement or purchase behaviours, compared with a comparable campaign that does not include this component?

The answer can be positive, neutral or negative. In all three cases, a properly constructed experiment produces useful knowledge. Its conditions must still make it possible to distinguish the effects of the format from those of the creative, targeting, media pressure or the brand’s prior awareness.

This is where measurement takes on particular importance. A first PoC cannot rest solely on the indicators produced by the solution being evaluated. Defining objectives in advance, building comparable groups, accessing data and, where possible, involving a third party specialised in measurement can help make its conclusions more credible.

The stakes go beyond mere reporting. An independent or methodologically controlled measurement makes it possible to distinguish what stems from the innovator’s promise from what can actually be attributed to their format. It guarantees neither a favourable result nor perfect causality, but it can make the decision to experiment more rational and the lessons more usable.

For the advertiser, the first investment then changes in nature. It is no longer only about buying an innovation whose success is assumed. It is about funding a bounded experiment whose costs, risks and evaluation criteria are known in advance.

This approach also assumes that innovators accept subjecting their hypotheses to real contradiction. An experiment that could only conclude in success would not truly be one. Conversely, a test that makes it possible to identify the conditions under which a solution does not add value can avoid much larger investments.

The first PoC could thus become less an exceptional risk-taking than a decision-making instrument shared between advertiser, agency, media and measurement partner. It still requires a player willing to take the initiative.

Conclusion — What if the real risk were never experimenting?

The advertising industry does not need to adopt every innovation presented to it. It must be able to question them, challenge their promises and reject those that meet no demonstrated need. Caution is not a flaw when it protects investments and the interests of brands.

But this caution deserves to be questioned when it leads to demanding, before any experiment, proof that only a first experiment could provide.

The examples of viewability, multiscreen measurement and the QR code show that the adoption of an innovation depends on a set of conditions that go well beyond its design alone. They also remind us that a market can take time to build the frameworks needed to recognise a new form of value.

Rigorous measurement can help reduce this uncertainty. Not by promising the success of every innovation, but by making it possible to establish which ones really add value, under what conditions and at what cost. In the end, the consumer and the advertiser may share a deeper question than it seems: how do you decide when not all the information is yet available?

The first PoC is not the reward of an innovation that has already succeeded. It is one of the methods for discovering whether it can succeed. And if the industry truly wishes to encourage innovation, the question is perhaps no longer only who will have the next good idea, but who will agree to help produce its first proof.

Erhalten Sie AdTrust in Ihrem LinkedIn-Postfach

Redaktionelle Perspektiven zu Vertrauen, Beweis und der Zukunft der Werbung.

AdTrust-Newsletter abonnieren ->