Skip to content

Advertising and media: should investment be mandated, or should the appetite to invest be rebuilt?

What if the media financing crisis also reveals a crisis in how their advertising value is perceived?

Faced with the concentration of digital investment around a handful of large platforms, the French government is considering requiring certain advertisers to allocate part of their digital advertising spend to political and general news publishers. The objective is legitimate: safeguarding pluralism and supporting publishers whose business models are under growing pressure.

But this response raises a deeper question. Can an advertising imbalance be durably corrected by mandating budget allocation, without addressing the reasons why advertisers today favour certain environments over others?

Because media are not necessarily lacking in strengths. They have content, audiences, trust relationships and editorial environments that brands continue to seek out. Their challenge is also to turn these qualities into economic value that is demonstrable enough to weigh in advertising trade-offs.

What if the real challenge were not only to redirect investment, but to rebuild the reasons to invest?

1. When regulation tries to correct a market imbalance

The French advertising-earmarking proposal starts from an observation that is hard to contest: digital advertising is heavily concentrated around a limited number of platforms, while the media that produce a significant share of professional and journalistic information struggle to capture a comparable share of investment.

According to the elements presented in the public debate, the envisaged scheme would apply to advertisers whose annual advertising spend exceeds one million euros. It would provide that a fraction of their digital investment be allocated to online political and general news publishers, at a rate set by decree and capped at 10%. This cap does not imply an immediate obligation to allocate 10% of all advertising budgets to the press. The scheme remains, at this stage, a legislative project whose terms and adoption are not yet settled.

The objective goes beyond advertising economics alone. Independent, diverse and accessible information is part of how democracy functions. Yet producing it requires significant human and editorial investment, in an environment where information distribution and attention capture are increasingly influenced by platforms and digital interfaces.

The question of timing also matters. Vincent Arvers, President of MediaSquare, points out that authorities often intervene several years after competitive advantages have taken root, when dominant positions are already entrenched. This observation highlights a structural difficulty: regulation enters a market whose equilibriums have sometimes been profoundly transformed before corrective measures can produce their effects.

But acknowledging the need for public intervention is not enough to demonstrate that any intervention will produce the intended results. A spending obligation can shift budgets. It does not guarantee where they come from, how effective they will be, or that beneficiary media will become more competitive on a lasting basis.

This is the whole ambiguity of the project: responding to a real economic emergency without necessarily solving the mechanisms that produced it.

2. Why do advertisers favour platforms?

To understand this concentration, advertiser decisions need to be looked at through something other than an opposition between legacy media and tech giants.

Digital platforms have progressively built integrated advertising environments. They enable audience targeting, rapid campaign activation, investment adjustments, access to granular data and — with methodological limitations — the ability to link advertising exposure to commercial outcomes.

This integration constitutes a considerable economic advantage. It reduces certain coordination costs, simplifies buying for many advertisers and provides indicators that can be used directly in their decision processes. It also strengthens dependence on proprietary environments, in which a single company can control a large share of distribution, data and measurement.

By comparison, traditional media long organised their offer around different logics: content quality, audience reach, editorial context, relationship with the public and valuation of ad space. These characteristics remain relevant, but on their own they do not always meet contemporary demands for comparison and investment justification.

It would nonetheless be misleading to portray all media as technologically outdated. Broadcast groups are developing their streaming platforms and targeting capabilities. Publishers are investing in first-party data, subscriptions, joint commercial offers and audience measurement. Some premium environments already offer sophisticated digital advertising solutions.

The problem is therefore not simply one of technological lag. It also lies in the ability of media to have their advantages recognised in a market whose buying criteria have profoundly changed.

An engaged audience, a credible editorial context or a lasting relationship with readers can create value for a brand. But how is that value assessed? How is it compared to other channels? And how does it enter budget allocation decisions?

The quality of a media environment can be a competitive advantage. One still has to be able to demonstrate its contribution to advertiser objectives.

3. Can a spending obligation recreate value?

This is where the debate becomes particularly interesting.

For supporters of advertising earmarking, public intervention could help rebalance the resources of a sector that is essential to pluralism. News publishers do not produce only advertising inventory: they perform a democratic function whose collective benefits exceed the revenue they are able to generate.

This argument deserves to be heard. Market mechanisms do not necessarily reward all the social benefits of independent information. It would therefore be reductive to judge any press-support policy solely by advertisers’ return on investment.

But the proposed mechanism raises another question: why should this responsibility fall primarily on companies’ advertising budgets?

Advertisers do not invest in media solely to fund them. They are looking for audiences, relevant environments, brand effects and — depending on their objectives — commercial results. A mandated spend does not automatically become an investment considered as performing.

There is also the risk of budget displacement rather than a rebalancing at the expense of dominant platforms. Nothing guarantees that amounts allocated to news publishers would come exclusively from spending previously placed with the large platforms. They could also come from the specialist press, broadcast media or other channels already subject to strong competition.

The scope of beneficiaries itself raises a question of pluralism. Political and general news publishers play an essential role, but specialist, professional, cultural and regional media, along with new editorial actors, also contribute to information diversity. A targeted mechanism can respond to a legitimate political priority while creating new differences in treatment between content producers.

Finally, indirect effects must be examined: administrative complexity, oversight costs, budget trade-offs, inventory price evolution or the maintenance of commissions levied by technology intermediaries. Part of the additional resources may not benefit journalism production directly.

You can require an advertiser to buy an ad space. You cannot require them to consider that space as a value creator.

This distinction does not necessarily condemn the project. It is simply a reminder that two different objectives are at stake: financing an activity of general interest, and rebuilding the commercial attractiveness of media.

The first can be a matter of public policy choice. The second requires a deeper transformation of the advertising value proposition.

4. Making investment attractive again: rebuilding the value of premium media

What if part of the answer lay in evolving how media present, commercialise and demonstrate their value?

Editorial quality, environment credibility and audience relationships are important assets. But they would gain from being more clearly linked to the concrete objectives of advertisers: attention, memorisation, consideration, trust, engagement and contribution to business outcomes.

That starts with making buying easier. More readable offers, pooled commercial schemes, comparable formats and better interoperability of measurement could reduce the coordination costs that today favour integrated platforms. It is not necessarily about imitating their model, but about removing the obstacles that make certain investments harder to plan, activate and evaluate.

The question of measurement is just as important. Premium media may offer environments that are favourable to advertising reception without this advantage automatically translating into better effectiveness. To establish that contribution, it must be possible to compare campaigns, isolate context effects and rely on methodologies credible enough to be accepted by advertisers, agencies and sales houses.

Advertising innovation also has a role to play. Interactive formats, formats combining advertising with verified consumer experiences, new approaches to attention measurement and incrementality evaluation methods open up interesting avenues. Their value, however, should not be assumed: it depends on their ability to produce results that are reproducible and significant enough to justify their cost.

This logic could help transform the relationship between media and advertisers. Rather than only asking for more investment in the name of content quality, media could strengthen their ability to demonstrate what their environments specifically bring to campaigns.

This does not mean every medium must become a performance platform, or that every piece of advertising creative can be reduced to a conversion indicator. Brand building, desirability and long-term effects are not measured like an immediate transaction. But the difficulty of measuring certain effects is no excuse for giving up on understanding them better.

A reconquest strategy therefore means defending the singularity of media while modernising the proofs of their value.

The press, broadcast media and other premium media do not necessarily need to become copies of the large platforms. They need to make their own advantages easier to buy, to compare and to value.

Conclusion — Supporting media is not enough. The reasons to invest in them must also be strengthened.

The debate over advertising earmarking reveals a deep tension between two legitimate imperatives: preserving the economic conditions of pluralism and respecting advertisers’ investment logic.

Public intervention can help support publishers weakened by market transformation. It can also be justified by democratic objectives that go beyond the immediate interests of businesses. But on its own it does not guarantee that media will durably regain a more significant place in advertising strategies.

Because the concentration of digital investment is not only the result of a regulatory imbalance. It also rests on advantages in distribution, data, technology integration and measurement that platforms have built over time.

The response cannot therefore be exclusively regulatory. It must also be economic, commercial and technological.

Premium media have qualities that advertisers continue to seek. Their challenge now is to better demonstrate how these qualities contribute to brand value, without giving up their editorial singularity.

Pluralism deserves to be supported. Advertising value deserves to be demonstrated.

And if the aim is to durably rebalance investment, the most important question may not only be what share of their budgets advertisers should be required to devote to media.

It is what will give them, tomorrow, more reasons to do so voluntarily.

Advertising innovation has its own Messy Middle: who agrees to go first?

Innovation occupies a singular place in the advertising industry. Conferences celebrate it, agencies claim it, advertisers seek it, and sales houses see in it an opportunity to renew their value proposition. Yet between the interest shown in an idea and the decision to experiment with it, there is sometimes a considerable distance.

This paradox does not necessarily reflect a lack of boldness. Organisations must protect their investments, justify their choices and demonstrate the effectiveness of the initiatives they fund. But how do you evaluate an innovation that, precisely because it is new, does not yet have the references needed to reassure its first users?

This difficulty recalls a well-known marketing mechanism: the Messy Middle, that space of exploration and evaluation in which the consumer hesitates before making a decision. What if companies, too, went through their own Messy Middle when they consider adopting an innovation?

1. Innovation appeals. The first commitment is another story.

In advertising, innovation enjoys a paradoxical advantage: almost no one wants to appear hostile to change. Advertisers look for new levers of effectiveness, agencies for new approaches for their clients, and media for solutions capable of differentiating their inventory. Yet this shared interest does not always turn into concrete decisions.

An idea can elicit a favourable reaction during a presentation, be judged relevant by several stakeholders and even address a recognised market problem, without any player deciding to fund its first experiment. This gap deserves study. It is not enough to explain the inaction by the caution of decision-makers: an innovation may also be insufficiently mature, poorly positioned or difficult to integrate into existing processes.

Consider a fictional example, but one representative of advertising decision circuits. A TV sales house discovers a new format combining advertising creative and verified consumer reviews. The idea interests it, but it would like an advertiser to first express an intention to try it. The media agency, consulted in turn, recognises the potential of the format while asking for measured results before recommending it to its client. The advertiser, for its part, waits for its agency to validate the relevance of the investment and for the sales house to confirm the broadcasting conditions. Each advances legitimate arguments. Yet several months can pass without any decision being made.

This mechanism reveals a difficulty less visible than resistance to change: the fragmentation of responsibility. The sales house does not want to mobilise its inventory without commercial demand, the agency hesitates to recommend a format lacking references, and the advertiser does not want to fund alone an experiment whose benefits remain uncertain. No one necessarily rejects the innovation, but no one simultaneously holds the means, the mandate and the interest to organise its first test. The absence of a decision ends up substituting for a genuine evaluation.

The risk is no longer only that of an innovation that would fail. It is that of an innovation that would never really be evaluated.

2. The Messy Middle: when the need for proof delays the decision

In 2020, researchers Alistair Rennie and Jonny Protheroe, in a study published by Google, proposed the concept of the Messy Middle to describe the complexity of the purchase journey. Between the triggering of a need and the final decision, the consumer does not necessarily progress in a linear way. They alternate between exploration and evaluation, discover new possibilities, compare offers and seek information likely to reduce their uncertainty.

Consumer reviews, recommendations and credibility signals can intervene in this process. Their value lies not only in their ability to reassure: they bring information complementary to the promise made by the brand. A verified purchase experience does not guarantee that a product will suit everyone, but it can help inform a decision.

This reading leads us to re-examine the role of advertising. A message can create attention and desirability without being enough to dispel the questions that separate interest from purchase. Associating advertising creative with proof of consumer experience could help bring these two moments closer. It would still be necessary to measure this effect under comparable conditions, rather than assuming that a mechanism observed in e-commerce will automatically reproduce in a TV or BVoD campaign.

But the parallel becomes particularly interesting when we observe the decisions of companies themselves. Faced with an innovation, marketing managers may adopt comparable behaviours: multiplying exchanges, consulting their partners, comparing solutions, requesting additional guarantees and deferring their commitment. The more uncertainty remains, the more the evaluation risks generating new requests for information.

It is obviously not a matter of claiming that the consumer’s behavioural model applies scientifically, without adaptation, to the investment decisions of organisations. A company has budgetary, legal and operational constraints that cannot be reduced to cognitive biases. But the analogy reveals a common tension: in both cases, the search for proof aims to reduce uncertainty, without necessarily eliminating it.

The consumer looks for proof before buying. The advertiser looks for proof before experimenting. In both cases, the question becomes that of the level of uncertainty acceptable in order to decide.

3. Those innovations that had to build their own legitimacy

The history of advertising and media technologies shows that the adoption of an innovation does not depend solely on its initial relevance. It often requires the convergence of uses, standards, measurement methods and economic interests.

Viewability offers a particularly revealing illustration. For a long time, digital advertising was mainly sold on the basis of served impressions, without these guaranteeing a genuinely visible exposure. The question of visibility gradually imposed new measurement requirements. In 2014, the Media Rating Council’s lifting of its advisory against the transactional use of viewable impressions marked an important step. The adoption of this measure nevertheless remained gradual. In 2015, the IAB still described a transition period, with technical difficulties and measurement discrepancies between vendors. The challenge was not only to create an indicator: the various players had to agree to use it as a common reference.

The evolution of television measurement in the United Kingdom tells another story. BARB began publishing BVoD consumption data in 2015, before introducing multiscreen audience measurement in 2018, then gradually broadening the coverage of screens and uses. This transformation did not consist of replacing an old measure with a new one overnight. It required bringing together different technical environments and market conventions to build a more coherent view of audiovisual consumption.

The QR code is a third example, further from measurement but just as instructive. Invented in 1994 by DENSO, it first met concrete industrial needs. Its adoption in consumer uses then depended on the evolution of phones, applications and behaviours. The technology existed well before the conditions for its everyday use were widely met. Its journey is a reminder that an innovation can be relevant in one environment without being so immediately in all others.

These examples do not prove that every innovation will eventually prevail with enough patience. Many disappear, sometimes for good reasons. They show rather that an idea becomes a market practice only when its benefits can be understood, its constraints mastered and its results evaluated according to criteria acceptable to those who must adopt it.

The difficulty of the first commitment cannot therefore be separated from building trust in the method itself.

4. The first PoC: buying a performance or funding knowledge?

When a company experiments with an innovation, it should not necessarily seek to confirm a commercial promise. It should first seek to answer a question precise enough to justify the test. In the case of a new advertising format, this question could be simple: does adding verified consumer proof improve the credibility of the message, its memorisation, engagement or purchase behaviours, compared with a comparable campaign that does not include this component?

The answer can be positive, neutral or negative. In all three cases, a properly constructed experiment produces useful knowledge. Its conditions must still make it possible to distinguish the effects of the format from those of the creative, targeting, media pressure or the brand’s prior awareness.

This is where measurement takes on particular importance. A first PoC cannot rest solely on the indicators produced by the solution being evaluated. Defining objectives in advance, building comparable groups, accessing data and, where possible, involving a third party specialised in measurement can help make its conclusions more credible.

The stakes go beyond mere reporting. An independent or methodologically controlled measurement makes it possible to distinguish what stems from the innovator’s promise from what can actually be attributed to their format. It guarantees neither a favourable result nor perfect causality, but it can make the decision to experiment more rational and the lessons more usable.

For the advertiser, the first investment then changes in nature. It is no longer only about buying an innovation whose success is assumed. It is about funding a bounded experiment whose costs, risks and evaluation criteria are known in advance.

This approach also assumes that innovators accept subjecting their hypotheses to real contradiction. An experiment that could only conclude in success would not truly be one. Conversely, a test that makes it possible to identify the conditions under which a solution does not add value can avoid much larger investments.

The first PoC could thus become less an exceptional risk-taking than a decision-making instrument shared between advertiser, agency, media and measurement partner. It still requires a player willing to take the initiative.

Conclusion — What if the real risk were never experimenting?

The advertising industry does not need to adopt every innovation presented to it. It must be able to question them, challenge their promises and reject those that meet no demonstrated need. Caution is not a flaw when it protects investments and the interests of brands.

But this caution deserves to be questioned when it leads to demanding, before any experiment, proof that only a first experiment could provide.

The examples of viewability, multiscreen measurement and the QR code show that the adoption of an innovation depends on a set of conditions that go well beyond its design alone. They also remind us that a market can take time to build the frameworks needed to recognise a new form of value.

Rigorous measurement can help reduce this uncertainty. Not by promising the success of every innovation, but by making it possible to establish which ones really add value, under what conditions and at what cost. In the end, the consumer and the advertiser may share a deeper question than it seems: how do you decide when not all the information is yet available?

The first PoC is not the reward of an innovation that has already succeeded. It is one of the methods for discovering whether it can succeed. And if the industry truly wishes to encourage innovation, the question is perhaps no longer only who will have the next good idea, but who will agree to help produce its first proof.

Why do good ideas die between silos, when an innovation belongs to everyone… but often ends up belonging to no one?

Some innovations seem to have every ingredient for success. They meet a real need, create value, and often draw the interest of many players. Yet many take years to actually reach their market.

Contactless payment is a good illustration. The technology existed, but its adoption required banks to issue the cards, networks to align their standards, merchants to upgrade their terminals, and consumers to change their habits.

So the problem doesn’t always lie in the idea itself. Sometimes it lies in how organizations and ecosystems are structured. When an innovation crosses several areas of expertise, several departments, or several partners, it can quickly end up without a true owner.

What if some good ideas don’t disappear for lack of value, but because no single player holds, on its own, the means — or the mandate — to make them adopted?

1. Organizations are built to manage expertise. Not cross-functional ideas.

Large organizations are built around a simple logic: split responsibilities in order to develop ever sharper expertise.

This specialization isn’t accidental. It’s the consequence of growing market complexity. It also answers a demand for performance. As each function grew more complex, it became impossible for a single team to master the entire advertising value chain.

Twenty years ago, a marketing director could still oversee a campaign built mainly around a TV film, a press plan, and an outdoor placement.

Today, a single campaign can simultaneously mobilize television, digital, retail media, social media, content creators, CRM, e-commerce, data, artificial intelligence, research, brand safety, and the regulatory issues tied to personal data.

Facing this complexity, organizations naturally specialized.

  • Marketing steers the brand.
  • Communications builds the messaging.
  • Media teams optimize investment.
  • CRM develops the customer relationship.
  • Consumer Experience teams improve the journey.
  • Data and AI teams use data to sharpen decisions.
  • Legal departments secure compliance.
  • Research institutes provide independent performance measurement.
  • Creative agencies imagine campaigns.
  • Media agencies orchestrate investment.
  • Sales houses value their inventory and commercialize their audiences.

This specialization is a formidable source of efficiency. It lets each function build expertise that no single person could reasonably master alone.

No one would ask a creative agency today to build an econometric model. Nor would anyone expect a research institute to design an ad campaign.

This specialization also serves another, often less visible purpose: risk management. In an industry where global advertising investment runs into several hundred billion euros a year, decisions rarely rest on a single person. They rely on recognized expertise, specialized partners, and independent third parties able to inform or de-risk the choices being made.

  • A media agency doesn’t just buy space. It informs trade-offs, de-risks investments, and puts its credibility behind the recommendations it makes.
  • A creative agency doesn’t just produce campaigns. It helps brands limit creative risk.
  • Likewise, research institutes, consultancies, and independent measurement experts help validate hypotheses before, during, or after a campaign.

Specialization, then, doesn’t just build skill. It’s also a collective risk-reduction mechanism.

This division of roles is therefore not just logical — it’s indispensable.

But this organizational structure also has a limit. The most promising innovations rarely respect the boundaries organizations have built for themselves.

They cross several areas of expertise, several departments, and often several companies. They require shared responsibility, and coordination between players who share neither the same objectives, nor the same budgets, nor the same success metrics.

Organizations were rarely designed for that. They excel at managing expertise. Their real challenge begins where value sits between functions.

2. When an innovation belongs to several functions, it often ends up belonging to none of them

Not all innovations face the same adoption difficulties. Some fit naturally within an already identified function. They quickly find a sponsor, a budget, and a decision process.

Others, by contrast, cross several areas of expertise at once. They touch brand, creative, media, research, customer relations, data, and compliance simultaneously.

The growth of Retail Media is a good illustration. It belongs exclusively to no one — not media teams, not e-commerce, not CRM, not data. Its rise depended precisely on the ability of these different areas of expertise to coordinate their decisions around a shared objective.

The arrival of generative AI illustrates the same phenomenon. Should it be led by IT, Data leadership, marketing, the business units, HR, or innovation leadership? In many companies, that question is still being fought over.

The wider the scope grows, the harder a simple question becomes to answer: who should actually own this innovation? The CMO? The media director? Consumer Insights? CRM? Communications? Legal? Or an innovation director, where one exists?

In most cases, everyone recognizes part of the value. But no single player holds, on its own, the legitimacy, the budget, or the performance metrics to make the call.

The more value an innovation creates across functions, the less obvious it becomes who should adopt it first.

Every organization has a clear map of its responsibilities. Far more rarely does it have a map of its cross-functional topics.

This isn’t a lack of interest, nor resistance to change. It’s simply a consequence of how responsibilities are distributed inside organizations.

A cross-functional innovation doesn’t just challenge habits. It challenges the boundary between functions itself.

And this is exactly where trade-offs get harder. A decision no longer just means choosing a solution. It also means determining who becomes responsible for it… and who agrees to carry the risk.

3. Silos don’t stop at the company’s walls

The difficulties faced by cross-functional innovations aren’t only explained by advertisers’ internal organization. They also stem from how the entire advertising industry has progressively structured itself.

Over the decades, the ecosystem has specialized around players whose expertise has become increasingly complementary.

  • Creative agencies imagine campaigns.
  • Media agencies build investment strategies and arbitrate media plans.
  • Sales houses commercialize and value their inventory.
  • Research institutes measure performance and bring an independent view.
  • Platforms build their technology and advertising environments.
  • Consultancies support organizational transformation.

This specialization is a formidable strength. It lets each player deepen its expertise, innovate in its own domain, and bring real added value to its clients. It also helps limit risk by relying on recognized, complementary expertise.

But, as within companies, this structure has a limit too. The most promising innovations don’t always fit within a single area of expertise. They can touch creative, media, measurement, data, customer experience, technology platforms, and regulatory compliance all at once.

A new question then emerges: who has the legitimacy to initiate the move?

The advertiser expressing a new need? The creative agency imagining new formats? The media agency steering investment? The sales house commercializing the space? The research institute validating the results? The tech vendor building the solution? Or the consultancy guiding the transformation?

In many cases, everyone holds part of the answer. But no single player holds, on its own, the responsibility or the legitimacy to carry the whole.

It is precisely in this space between areas of expertise that some innovations struggle to find their place.

The advertising industry has become extraordinarily good at organizing expertise. It remains more complex when it comes to organizing what connects that expertise.

When an innovation manages, despite everything, to bring these different players together, one final question remains: how can its value be demonstrated in a way that’s shared and credible?

4. An innovation only becomes a market once an ecosystem agrees to carry it

Disruptive ideas only take hold once a group of players progressively decides to adopt them. Payment standards, contactless, Retail Media, or generative AI didn’t take hold because a single company decreed them.

They developed because advertisers, tech vendors, agencies, institutes, regulators, and sometimes standards bodies progressively converged on the same direction.

An innovation then stops being seen as an isolated initiative. It becomes a new language shared across an entire market.

Recent history is full of examples.

The QR code, created in 1994, stayed confined to a handful of industrial uses for decades. It took the arrival of smartphones, native code readers built into cameras, and the acceleration of use during the Covid-19 pandemic for it to become an everyday standard.

Electric vehicles follow a similar logic. Their development doesn’t depend on carmakers alone. It also relies on energy providers, charging operators, local authorities, regulators, battery manufacturers and, of course, consumers. Improvements in battery technology, the build-out of charging infrastructure, and its interoperability have progressively removed several barriers to adoption.

In both cases, it wasn’t a technology that created the market. It was an ecosystem. That shift matters.

An innovation no longer just needs to convince a decision-maker. It has to progressively convince a market.

This also explains why some ideas take years to emerge. Their challenge isn’t only technological or commercial. It’s organizational too. Before transforming a market, they have to succeed in aligning the players that make it up.

That alignment requires one essential condition: the ability to demonstrate the value created in a way that’s shared and credible.

Without a common language, a shared reference framework, and a recognized measure, even the best ideas struggle to become standards.

Conclusion

Silos aren’t a design flaw. They’re the logical result of an industry that has become ever more expert.

But when value is created between functions, companies, or disciplines, a new form of coordination becomes essential.

The most promising innovations aren’t always the ones with the best technology. They’re often the ones that manage to unite an ecosystem, speak a common language, and demonstrate their value in a way shared and credible enough for everyone to agree to become part of it.

An innovation never becomes a market simply because it works. It becomes a market when an entire ecosystem agrees to carry it.

The Trust Budget Paradox. Why everyone talks about trust… but nobody buys it.

There is a striking paradox in advertising today. Ask almost any CMO, brand director, media lead, or agency executive, and they will tell you that trust has become a strategic priority. Consumers read reviews, look for proof, compare, and validate before they buy. They put more weight on other consumers’ experiences than on advertising claims alone. This is now widely accepted as fact.

Yet open any marketing budget and a different reality appears. Trust is almost never on it.

1. Everyone believes in trust. Almost no one funds it.

The budget lines are well known.

  • Creative
  • Production
  • Media buying
  • CRM
  • Retail media
  • Influence
  • Data
  • Research
  • AI
  • Performance

But where is the line called Trust, Proof, or Validation? Almost nowhere. Trust is assumed to improve every other line. But it almost never exists as an identified investment in its own right.

This may come down to how the market still perceives it. For many professionals, trust isn’t an activatable lever. It’s treated as the byproduct of a broader posture: product quality, brand consistency, accumulated reputation, advertising territory, customer experience, and message coherence over time.

In other words, trust is seen as something built indirectly, almost organically — rarely something that can be isolated, activated, measured, or reinforced through a specific media mechanism.

This is where the contrast with attention becomes interesting. Attention, by comparison, has been progressively broken down, modeled, quantified, sold, and optimized. The industry talks in seconds of attention, completion rates, viewability, recall, exposure time. It has learned to treat a few moments of mental availability as a full economic resource — turning those few seconds into a central battleground, in an era that media theorist Bruno Patino has described as the age of the goldfish, where attention spans keep shrinking.

Trust, on the other hand, remains far less instrumented. Everyone knows it matters, that it shapes decisions, that it conditions how messages land. But it is rarely treated as an activatable layer of media performance.

This is probably one of the industry’s most interesting paradoxes: everyone agrees trust is strategic, but very few organizations know where to place it in a budget, a media plan, or a measurement model.

2. Trust belongs to no one.

Why does trust remain so hard to turn into an actual investment? Perhaps because, in practice, it belongs to no single team.

Inside the advertiser’s organization, trust is everywhere… but rarely anyone’s direct responsibility.

  • Product teams work on quality.
  • CRM manages the customer relationship.
  • Consumer Experience teams improve the journey.
  • Communications builds reputation.
  • Marketing develops brand territory.
  • Agencies imagine campaigns.
  • Sales houses commercialize media.
  • Research institutes sometimes measure it.
  • Platforms exploit it in their algorithms.

Everyone contributes to building trust. But no one truly owns it. There is generally no head of trust, no dedicated budget, no shared metric capable of managing trust as an economic asset in its own right.

This fragmentation may explain why trust so often ends up as a consequence rather than an operational objective.

This situation is all the more paradoxical given that the industry is constantly searching for new sources of credibility. Influencers are a good example. For several years, they answered the growing distrust of traditional advertising through a relationship with their communities perceived as more personal and authentic.

But as commercial partnerships multiply, their role is shifting too. They are becoming progressively integrated into the advertising economy itself. In other words, they are no longer just content creators — they are also becoming ad formats.

This evolution isn’t abnormal. It’s even logical. But it points to a deeper truth: no channel, no spokesperson, and no format enjoys a permanently inexhaustible reserve of trust. Trust cannot be declared. It is built, verified… and renewed.

This may be the real challenge of the coming years. If trust belongs neither to brands, nor to agencies, nor to media, nor even to content creators, then it becomes a collective asset that the industry has to learn to organize.

And it is precisely because it belongs to no one today that trust still struggles to earn its own budget line. When an asset has no clearly identified owner, it rarely becomes a priority investment.

3. Premium and participation are not incompatible.

This may be where one of the industry’s last great misconceptions still lives.

Over the past fifteen years, consumer reviews have become embedded across many sectors. They are now nearly unavoidable in travel, hospitality, restaurants, electronics, retail, automotive, financial services, and even healthcare, where they directly influence purchase decisions.

Yet in the most premium categories, the picture looks very different. Luxury houses, fine watchmaking, jewelry, high-end automotive brands, and many heritage brands rarely put customer reviews at the center of their brand experience or communications.

As if premium and participation belonged to two incompatible worlds. This perception is understandable. For a long time, reviews were associated with marketplaces, price comparison sites, e-commerce product pages, and transactional platforms. In that world, the logic is primarily functional: compare, reassure, decide.

The premium territory follows a different logic. It seeks to build desirability, rarity, emotion, brand culture, and imagination. The fear is natural: would bringing consumer reviews into that world dilute it?

The question is worth asking. But it may rest on a misunderstanding. A review does not, on its own, determine whether a piece of communication is premium or not. It is the creative execution, the media context, and the editorial craft that give it meaning and value.

A handful of authentic experiences, curated by a brand and its agency and woven into a demanding creative or editorial environment, have nothing in common with a wall of comments on a product page. The media, the creative, and the art direction fundamentally change the nature of that proof.

In other words, premium is not the opposite of reviews. It may in fact be exactly what gives them their strongest value. Premium media have always known how to select, editorialize, and contextualize content. Why couldn’t the same logic apply tomorrow to certain forms of consumer proof?

What if the real question were no longer: “Can premium brands display reviews?” But rather: “How can premium brands turn a handful of authentic proof points into a new communications asset, without giving up their brand territory?”

Conclusion

For years, the industry has built increasingly sophisticated infrastructures for distribution, targeting, measurement, and optimization. Trust, meanwhile, is still largely treated as a byproduct.

What if the real challenge of the coming years were to give it its own economic status? Not as a vague promise or a secondary KPI, but as an identifiable layer of value creation.

AdTrust’s first cycle explored one idea: trust could become infrastructure. The second begins with another question: why doesn’t a resource everyone considers essential have its own budget line yet?

Everything that creates durable value eventually earns its own line in the budget. The real question may no longer be whether trust deserves a budget… but when.

This question deserves a wider debate across the industry. AdTrust will keep exploring this territory in the editorial cycles ahead.

Cannes celebrates creativity. But the next battle may be fought elsewhere.

Every year, in mid-June, Cannes Lions becomes once again the symbolic centre of the advertising world. Since 1954, the festival has celebrated the most striking campaigns, craft, creativity, the boldness of brands and advertising’s ability to produce emotion, desirability and culture.

That function has not disappeared. It remains essential, in fact. Advertising needs strong ideas, narratives, distinctiveness and creative talent.

But Cannes no longer tells only that story.

As the festival has expanded far beyond the Palais, it has also become the reflection of another transformation: the shift of advertising value toward platforms, technological infrastructures, data, AI, creator ecosystems and measurement systems. In other words, the world’s largest celebration of creativity increasingly resembles a vast showcase of the players shaping the economic conditions of advertising itself.

That is precisely what this special edition of AdTrust sets out to examine.

Cannes is no longer only a creative festival. It is also a showcase of advertising infrastructures.

What is striking at Cannes today is not only the quality of the award-winning campaigns or the density of the conferences. It is the way the festival has turned into a parallel ecosystem made of beaches, rooftops, villas, ports, studios, immersive experiences and activations where commercial conversations matter as much as creative discussions.

Within this expanded space, the major American technology and advertising platforms occupy a particularly visible place. Meta, Amazon, TikTok, Google, Adobe, Microsoft, Spotify, Pinterest, Snap, Reddit, along with the major players in adtech and retail media, no longer come to Cannes merely to support the creative ecosystem. They install their formats, their demonstrations, their tools, their interfaces and their narratives around AI, creators, measurement, performance or commerce.

This shift matters.

For a long time, Cannes could be seen as the grand mass of the advertising idea. It now also resembles a full-scale marketplace of platforms, data, automation and activation environments — with a particularly visible presence of the players already capturing a growing share of the budgets once allocated to premium media.

This is not a reproach. It is a market fact.

The platforms have conquered dominant positions across essential layers: attention, distribution, targeting, measurement, commerce, creators, optimization and, increasingly, the orchestration tools themselves. It is therefore logical that they occupy Cannes. But their growing visibility says something deeper: the advertising battle is no longer fought only over ideas or inventory. It is also fought over the mastery of the invisible layers that organize performance.

And that raises a fundamental question for premium media.

Faced with the power of the platforms, European media are still looking for their own stage.

While Cannes has become a showcase of the major American infrastructures, it is not reducible to their dominance. What remains interesting about the festival is precisely that it still lets other geographies, other professional cultures and other visions of advertising come through.

For BuyTryShare, this is first visible in one very concrete place: RTL La Plage.

At a moment when part of the Croisette looks like a show of force by the global platforms, the presence of RTL AdAlliance is a reminder that a European media player can still exist at Cannes as something other than a mere spectator. For BuyTryShare, this presence is not abstract: RTL AdAlliance is among the rare European media players with which the project has already been able to open a concrete dialogue about other forms of value. This matters, not because it would prove anything on its own, but because it is a reminder that, amid the noise of the platform economy, some European media players remain able to explore trajectories other than the sole race for scale, data or automation.

In a different register, initiatives such as La French Connexion also play an interesting role. Not as a counter-power to the tech giants — that would be excessive — but as a rallying point for a French, and more broadly European, community that refuses to reduce Cannes to a mere theatre of platform activation. By bringing together brands, media, agencies, entrepreneurs and partners in a shared space, they are a reminder that there still exists a French, European, creative and relational anchoring in the industry — an anchoring that does not deny the international dimension of the market, but refuses to dissolve entirely within it.

These signals remain modest against the power of the major American ecosystems. But they are useful, because they show that the question is not only who occupies the most square metres on the Croisette. The real question is whether premium European media, sales houses, broadcasters and creative players can still defend a value proposition of their own in a market whose infrastructure is increasingly shifting elsewhere.

The point, then, is not to lament the dominance of the platforms. It is to understand what strategic space remains for premium European media in a market deeply reconfigured by them.

In other words: if the platforms win scale, data, automation and a growing share of the commercial stage, what remains distinctive about premium media?

If the platforms dominate the infrastructure, premium media may have to win back the battle for trust.

This is precisely the question that has run through the past six months of AdTrust.

Across 35 articles, this newsletter has explored the rise of consumer reviews, social proof, validation, participation, the transformations of the advertising market and the idea that a new layer of trust could emerge within media themselves. One conviction has gradually taken hold: attention is no longer enough.

In a market saturated with messages, the next battle is no longer fought only over reach, frequency or buying efficiency. It is also fought over credibility.

Consumers no longer simply receive messages. They verify them, compare them, comment on them, confront them with other experiences, and increasingly look for visible proof before deciding. And while the platforms excel at distribution, optimization and capturing attention, the question remains open on another terrain: that of visible trust, proof, editorial context and validation.

This may be where premium media can still recover a structural advantage.

Not by trying to imitate the platforms on their own ground. Not by dreaming of becoming European clones of Meta, Google or Amazon. But by asking what they can offer that the platforms cannot buy as easily: editorial context, a stronger relationship with the media brand, cultural credibility, and perhaps tomorrow the ability to host visible layers of proof, participation and validation within trusted environments.

That, at least, is the territory AdTrust intends to explore in its next cycle.

The first cycle made it possible to establish the diagnosis: the shift from exposure to validation, the rise of participating audiences, the transformation of reviews into potential assets, the emergence of a possible trust infrastructure.

The second will be closer to the ground. It will focus less on the general idea that trust matters — the market already knows that — than on the real conditions of its activation.

In other words, the coming editions of AdTrust will be organized around five more concrete questions:

  • why does trust still have no budget line?
  • why do good ideas die between the silos?
  • what exactly is the economic value of proof?
  • what does it take to make trust operational within a campaign?
  • why is the first buyer almost always the hardest to convince?

Cannes remains a celebration of creativity. But this year, it also appears as a useful reminder: the future of advertising will not be shaped by creativity alone.

It will also be shaped by those who control the infrastructures, the data, the interfaces, the measurement systems — and perhaps tomorrow, the trust layer itself.

If Cannes is a reminder this week of who already controls attention, the next question for premium media may be even more decisive: who will know how to become credible again, at the very moment when consumers themselves now demand proof?

From Theory to Reality

For the past six months, AdTrust has explored a simple but increasingly important question: “What happens when trust becomes a strategic asset in advertising?”

Along the way, we have examined the growing influence of consumer reviews, the limits of attention as a standalone metric, the emergence of validation mechanisms, the rise of participation within media environments, and most recently, the idea that trust itself could become a new layer of advertising infrastructure. Taken individually, these topics may appear distinct. Together, however, they point toward the same conclusion: in a world saturated with messages, credibility is becoming as important as visibility.

This edition is slightly different from the previous ones. Rather than introducing a new concept, it marks a transition. Because at some point, every theory must be confronted with reality.

Over the past months, the ideas explored through AdTrust have progressively taken a more tangible form. BuyTryShare is now operating as a company, a first MVP has been launched, the Proof ROI Engine is live, and a new website has been built to support the next phase of the journey.

The question is therefore evolving. Until now, the objective was to understand whether these ideas made sense. From now on, the objective is to discover whether they create enough value to be tested by the market. This article reflects on that transition: from reflection to experimentation, from theory to reality.

What Six Months of Reflection Revealed

When AdTrust started this journey, the initial focus was relatively narrow. The objective was to explore the growing influence of consumer reviews and understand why they had become such a powerful factor in modern purchasing decisions.

The hypothesis seemed straightforward: consumers increasingly trust other consumers more than they trust brands. But as the research progressed, something unexpected happened.

The discussion moved beyond reviews. It became a discussion about advertising itself. About attention, about credibility, about media economics, about the growing gap between what brands say and what consumers believe.

Article after article, a recurring pattern emerged: the advertising industry has spent decades building increasingly sophisticated infrastructures to distribute messages, target audiences, optimize delivery and measure performance.

Yet one critical question remained largely unanswered: “What makes a message believable once it has been delivered?”

The more this question was explored, the more it became clear that reviews were not the real subject; trust was. Consumer reviews were simply one visible manifestation of a much larger phenomenon.

Consumers are no longer passive recipients of advertising. They verify, they compare, they search for validation, they seek proof before making decisions.

In that sense, the market may not be moving from advertising to reviews. It may be moving from messaging to validation, from attention to credibility, from exposure to proof.

And if that observation is correct, then the implications extend far beyond consumer reviews alone. They affect brands, agencies, media companies and perhaps the future architecture of advertising itself.

When an Idea Meets Reality

Ideas are easy to discuss in theory. Markets are less forgiving.

A concept can appear intellectually compelling, supported by research, aligned with consumer behavior and validated by industry trends. Yet none of this guarantees adoption.

At some point, every hypothesis faces the same test: will someone be willing to invest time, resources and budget to prove it works? This is where the journey now changes.

For six months, AdTrust explored the conditions that might justify a new approach to advertising: the rise of consumer validation, the growing importance of trust, the limits of attention-based metrics and the emergence of proof as a driver of decision-making.

The next step is no longer to understand these forces. It is to determine whether they can be translated into something operational. Over the past months, this transition has gradually taken shape:

  • BuyTryShare is now operating as a company.
  • A first MVP has been built.
  • The Proof ROI Engine is live.
  • A new website has been launched.
  • The first discussions with advertisers, agencies and media companies are underway.

None of these milestones prove that the model will succeed. But they do something equally important: they transform an idea into a testable proposition. That distinction matters.

Too many concepts remain trapped in presentations, conferences and thought leadership articles. They generate interest, conversations and sometimes even enthusiasm, but never reach the stage where they can be challenged by reality.

The market ultimately acts as the final validator. Not because it is always right, but because it forces clarity. It reveals:

  • whether a problem is important enough to solve,
  • whether the proposed solution creates measurable value,
  • whether the timing is right.

The coming months will therefore be different from the previous ones. The objective is no longer to refine a theory. The objective is to learn from experimentation, because every innovation eventually reaches a point where the question changes. From “Is this idea interesting?” to “Is this idea useful?”

What Happens If Trust Becomes Measurable?

One of the most interesting lessons from the past decade is that markets tend to value what they can measure.

  • Attention became valuable when it could be quantified.
  • Audience data became valuable when it could be activated.
  • Attribution became valuable when it could be linked to outcomes.

The same question now emerges for trust. For years, trust has been treated as an intangible concept: brands invest heavily to build it, media companies rely on it to preserve their credibility, consumers use it to make decisions. Yet trust itself often remains difficult to observe, compare and quantify.

As a result, many organizations continue to manage it indirectly through proxy metrics such as awareness, consideration, preference or Net Promoter Score.

These indicators are useful, but they do not always answer a fundamental business question: what is the economic value of increased trust?

This question became one of the motivations behind the development of the Proof ROI Engine. Not because a model can perfectly predict reality — it cannot. But because hypotheses become more useful when they can be translated into scenarios, assumptions and measurable outcomes.

If trust influences attention, consideration and conversion, then it should be possible to estimate its potential impact, not as certainty, but as a framework for discussion. This distinction is important.

The objective is not to claim that trust automatically generates results. The objective is to understand under which conditions trust can create value, for whom, and to what extent.

In many ways, this reflects a broader evolution taking place across the industry. Advertising is progressively moving away from assumptions and toward evidence. From intuition toward experimentation, from declarations toward validation. And perhaps that is where the next phase begins.

Not with the certainty that a new model will succeed, but with the willingness to test whether credibility itself can become a measurable driver of media performance.

Because if trust can be measured, activated and improved, it stops being a purely qualitative concept — it becomes an economic variable. And economic variables tend to reshape markets.

The Next Chapter Begins

The purpose of AdTrust was never to predict the future. Its purpose was to ask questions that the industry may need to confront sooner rather than later. What happens when:

  • consumers trust people more than brands?
  • validation becomes as important as visibility?
  • credibility becomes a competitive advantage?
  • trust itself starts behaving like an economic asset?

Over the past six months, these questions have shaped every article published in this series. Some conclusions remain open to debate, others will undoubtedly evolve as technology, regulation and consumer behavior continue to change.

But one observation appears increasingly difficult to ignore. The advertising industry is entering a new phase — not because advertising is disappearing, not because media are losing their relevance, but because audiences are becoming more active participants in the process.

They do not simply receive messages: they evaluate them, they verify them, they discuss them. And ultimately, they contribute to the credibility of brands themselves.

In that context, trust is no longer just a consequence of communication. It is becoming part of the communication system itself.

Whether this evolution leads to new formats, new measurement frameworks or entirely new business models remains to be seen. The market will decide. That is precisely what makes the next stage so interesting.

Until now, AdTrust has been a space for reflection. The next chapter will increasingly be about observation, experimentation and learning. Because the most important question is no longer whether these ideas are intellectually appealing. It is whether they create measurable value in the real world.

And there is only one way to find out. To test them. The journey continues.

Why the ‘bottom of the funnel’ is impoverishing brands…

The bottom of the funnel did not “win”. It was over-invested.

For more than ten years, the work of Les Binet and Peter Field has documented a counterintuitive but now well-established phenomenon: brands that over-invest in the short term at the expense of the long term end up paying more for each point of performance, while gradually weakening their brand equity.

In other words, the bottom of the funnel did not become dominant because it was inherently superior. It became dominant because it was easier to measure, quicker to justify, and more reassuring in a high-pressure environment.

In Media in Focus and Selling Creativity Short, Binet and Field clearly demonstrate that:

  • the short term (activation, promotion, tactical targeting) is effective for generating immediate sales,

  • the long term (emotional creativity, mass media, narrative consistency) is the main driver of sustainable growth,

  • and that upsetting this balance — by sacrificing the long term — automatically leads to a destruction of value in the medium and long term.

This point is fundamental: performance has never been the enemy of the brand. It is its exclusive overinvestment that poses a problem. By reducing marketing to what is immediately measurable — CPA, ROAS, last click, real-time attribution — many brands have gradually abandoned what cannot be measured instantly, but nevertheless creates most of the value: desirability, memorability, brand preference.

The result is paradoxical:

  • In the short term, indicators appear to be improving.

  • In the medium term, acquisition costs are increasing.

  • In the long term, the brand is eroding, becoming interchangeable and dependent on activation.

As Binet and Field show, ‘short-term thinking sells, long-term thinking grows. Confusing the two destroys value.’

At BuyTryShare, we firmly believe that customer proof is what allows us to become measurable again in the long term, without distorting it.

Performance has never been the enemy of the brand. The problem lies in reducing marketing to what is immediately measurable…

And it is precisely this imbalance — documented for over a decade — that largely explains the current tensions between creativity, traditional media and business demands.

Traditional media have not lost their effectiveness

They have lost touch with the evidence. The relative decline in investment in traditional media is often interpreted as a loss of effectiveness.

This is a simplistic interpretation — and largely incorrect. Academic research and market studies show that television, print media and cinema remain the most powerful media for building brand awareness, recall and preference. They continue to operate where pure performance fails: in building long-term relationships.

The problem, then, is not that these media no longer work. The problem is that they have been gradually disconnected from the moment of validation. In other words, they still trigger emotion, interest and desire… but they no longer offer immediate continuity to proof.

In the past, this disconnect was not an issue. Advertising enjoyed implicit credibility. The brand spoke, and the message was generally accepted.

Today, that capital has eroded. Contemporary consumers are neither hostile to advertising nor passive. They have become reflexively suspicious. They watch. They listen. But they check.

And when advertising offers no explicit path to proof, it is circumvented. Not rejected — but simply incomplete.

This is precisely what explains a paradox that has been observable for several years:

  • Traditional media continue to generate emotional impact,

  • but struggle to defend their business contribution in the face of channels perceived as more ‘actionable’,

  • even though their role in brand building remains decisive..

In reality, they have been locked into an artificial opposition:

  • on the one hand, mass media for image,

  • on the other, platforms for proof and performance.

This separation has benefited the platforms. But it has weakened the ecosystem as a whole.

The real issue, then, is not creativity. Nor is it media power. Nor even audience fragmentation. The real issue is the lack of a bridge between exposure and validation.

When advertising triggers a desire without offering the possibility of immediate verification, it leaves the consumer alone with their doubts — and automatically loses some of its value.

The paradox is therefore as follows:

  • Traditional media remain essential for brand building,

  • but are increasingly less recognised as business drivers,

  • because they no longer incorporate the logic of proof that has become central to the purchasing process.

This is not inevitable. It is a problem of design, not relevance.

At BuyTryShare, we start from a simple belief: proof should not replace the power of traditional media. It should complement it.

Advertising is not intended to become a place for consultation. But it can — and must — once again become the moment when credibility is at stake. By reconnecting mass media with customer evidence, it becomes possible to:

  • preserve their emotional and narrative role,

  • while giving them measurable continuity towards validation.

Traditional media have not lost their value. They have lost a link. And it is precisely this link — between creation, exposure and proof — that now determines their ability to remain central to marketing strategies.

What platforms understood before anyone else:

immediate verifiability.

The reason why platforms have gradually captured an increasing share of advertising value is not solely because they are more efficient, more creative or more technologically innovative.

This is primarily because they understood a simple reality very early on: in a world of mistrust, any promise must be immediately verifiable. On platforms, advertising is never isolated. It is systematically surrounded by validation signals:

  • visible reviews and ratings,

  • comments,

  • recommendations,

  • user-generated content

  • instant exploration possibilities.

Exposure and proof coexist in the same environment. This continuity changes everything.

When an advertisement attracts interest on a platform, consumers do not need to leave the site to check it out.

The proof is there, accessible, integrated, sometimes even imposed. It is not so much a question of trust in the platform itself. It is a question of immediately reducing doubt.

The platform does not ask consumers to believe. It allows them to verify.

This is precisely what has made these environments so effective in terms of performance. Not because advertising is more persuasive there, but because the path between intention and validation is short, fluid and measurable.

Conversely, traditional media have long operated on a different model:

  • exposure here,

  • verification elsewhere,

  • decision later.

This model was viable as long as advertising enjoyed implicit credibility. That is no longer the case today. However, it would be wrong to conclude that platforms have ‘won’ through creative or cultural superiority. They have won because they have been able to meet an expectation that has become central: the ability to validate a promise without friction.

But this gain has come at the cost of several well-known adverse effects:

  • standardisation of messages,

  • constant pressure to deliver short-term results,

  • increased reliance on activation,

  • and growing difficulty in building truly distinctive brands.

In other words, platforms excel at conversion. They are much less effective at building sustainable brand value.

The real challenge, therefore, is not to imitate platforms. Nor is it to transform traditional media into transactional environments. The real challenge lies elsewhere: it consists of reintroducing immediate verifiability where emotion, desirability and preference are built.

That is to say, at the heart of mass media. When television, press or cinema advertising triggers strong emotions but offers no explicit access to evidence, it leaves consumers suspended between interest and doubt.

Conversely, when a creative message is immediately accompanied by credible evidence, it does not lose its emotional power. It gains legitimacy. This is where the historical separation between branding and performance shows its limitations.

Verifiability is not an attribute of the bottom of the funnel. It is a cross-cutting requirement that has become structural in all decision-making processes.

Platforms understood this before anyone else. Traditional media can now reclaim it — without giving up what makes them strong.

At BuyTryShare, we start from a simple observation: proof is not the enemy of creativity. It has become its prerequisite for credibility.

By reconnecting the emotional power of traditional media with certified, immediately actionable customer evidence, it becomes possible to:

  • maintain the impact of the top of the funnel,

  • meet contemporary validation requirements,

  • and finally move beyond the sterile opposition between image and performance.

Platforms have understood the importance of verifiability. Traditional media have mastered the art of creating symbolic value. The challenge now is to bring the two together.

And it is precisely here that the future of advertising effectiveness is being played out.

Finally reconciling evidence, creativity and value

The debate between branding and performance is a false one. What has weakened brands in recent years is neither creativity, nor moderation, nor the pursuit of ROI.

It was separating emotion from evidence, exposure from validation, the long term from the measurable. The bottom of the funnel did not win. It was overinvested in, for lack of anything better.

Traditional media have not lost their power. They have lost their continuity towards evidence.

Platforms did not triumph through creative superiority.

They simply understood, before others did, that every promise had to be verifiable.

The challenge is therefore not to choose between image and performance. The challenge is to make the top of the funnel credible, measurable and actionable again, without distorting it. This is precisely the role of customer proof.

At BuyTryShare, we firmly believe that certified social proof is neither a gimmick nor just another marketing tool. It is the missing piece that allows traditional media to regain their full economic value, while respecting their cultural and creative role.

In an age of mistrust, advertising will not win by promising more. It will win by allowing verification.

And this is exactly where BuyTryShare comes in.

Why certified reviews are becoming the ultimate weapon against advertising mistrust

This graph does not say ‘opinions have no place in advertising’

At first glance, this graph may seem counterintuitive to those who advocate for the integration of customer reviews into the advertising world. Only 4% of respondents cite advertising as their preferred channel for reading reviews, compared to 46% for Google and 34% for the brand’s website. Some will see this as a definitive condemnation: ‘Reviews have no place in advertising.’

It’s a quick read. And above all, it’s a misreading. What this graph actually measures is not the usefulness of reviews in advertising, but where consumers go to find proof when they are already in decision-making mode. In other words, it answers the question: ‘When I want to check something, where do I go?’ The answer is perfectly logical:

  • Google to compare and cross-reference sources,

  • the brand’s website to confirm the offer,

  • sometimes email or social media,

  • and very rarely advertising, which historically has never been designed as a space for consultation.

The classic mistake: confusing the place of evidence with the time of evidence. This is where the fundamental confusion lies.

  • A place of discovery is a space designed for exploring, reading, comparing and delving deeper.

  • A moment of discovery is a moment triggered by an exhibition, an emotion, a promise or a desire.ie.

Advertising has never been — and never will be — a place for proof in the strict sense of the word. No one expects to read dozens of customer reviews in a television advert, a newspaper page or a poster. And that’s fine.

But advertising is, by its very nature, the moment when the need for proof arises. It is precisely when an advertisement works — when it captures attention, arouses interest, creates a projection — that the modern consumer’s reflex kicks in:

  • ‘Okay… but is it true?’

  • ‘Have others experienced it?’

  • ‘Can I verify it?’

What this graph really reveals is that advertising is bypassed if it does not trigger access to proof. The key figure is therefore not just 4%. The key figure is what it implies. It shows that:

  • Advertising alone is no longer considered credible by default.

  • Consumers have developed a systematic validation reflex,

  • and this reflex is exercised elsewhere… immediately after exposure.

Advertising is not rejected. It is bypassed when it offers no path to proof. It is not a problem of creativity, format or GRP. It is a problem of cognitive continuity between the message and validation.

So the real question is not ‘where do people read reviews?’ It is much more strategic: Does advertising allow access to evidence at the exact moment when interest is triggered?

This is where everything comes into play. And this is precisely where the intelligent integration of certified reviews — not as content to be consumed, but as a signal of credibility and a gateway to verification — becomes decisive.

Advertising should not host the evidence. It should activate the evidence reflex at the right time, in the right places, in a fluid, explicit and measurable way.

It is this shift—from isolated messages to verifiable messages—that is redefining advertising effectiveness today. And this graph, far from invalidating this approach, is one of the clearest demonstrations of it.

BuyTryShare does not include reviews in advertising

It activates them through advertising. This is undoubtedly the most misunderstood — yet most fundamental — aspect of the BuyTryShare approach. Contrary to popular belief, BuyTryShare does not seek to transform advertising into a review platform. Television does not become a Tripadvisor. The press does not turn into a comment forum.

Above all, advertising does not become a place for consultation. It remains what it has always been, and what it does best: a trigger.

Advertising as a cognitive bridge, not as a destination

In the modern consumer’s thought process, advertising plays a very specific role:

  • It creates the spark.

  • It captures attention.

  • It projects a use.

  • It triggers a desire.

But the moment this interest arises, a second mechanism automatically kicks in: ‘Can I verify this?’

This is where most advertising campaigns end. The message is broadcast… then left alone, with no follow-up.

BuyTryShare comes into play precisely at this point: between exposure and verification. Advertising does not become proof. It becomes the point of access to proof.

Why format, duration and design are strategic

This role of ‘cognitive bridge’ requires very specific choices — and commitment.

  • A short format (5 seconds)

    Because it is not a matter of lengthy persuasion, but of pointing things out.

    Evidence does not need a speech. It needs credible evidence.

  • A certified average mark

    Because it acts as an immediate cognitive shortcut.

    A simple, universal signal that can be understood in a fraction of a second.

  • A real customer quote

    Because he embodies proof.

    He does not speak ‘on behalf of the brand’, but on behalf of a peer.

  • An explicit promise: ‘genuine reviews, verified customers’

    Because trust can no longer be assumed. It must be expressed.

  • A visible and unapologetic QR code

    Not a technological gadget, but an interface that makes advertising verifiable again.

    Because it embodies the call to action: ‘Want to check? You can. Right now.’

It is not a technological gadget. It is a mental interface between mass media and individual action.

BuyTryShare does not compete with Google or the brand’s website

He feeds them with an already warm intent. This is a fundamental point: Google remains the natural place for verification, and the brand’s website remains the space for reassurance and conversion.

BuyTryShare does not seek to replace them. It directs users towards them, but with one major difference: the intention is no longer cold, it is triggered, contextualised and measurable.

Consumers do not ‘stumble upon’ a review page. They arrive there because a trusted media outlet has triggered their need for proof. That is what makes the difference:

  • an interactive exposure,

  • an intentional impression

  • a measurable GRP signal.

The real paradigm shift: from ‘declarative’ advertising to ‘verifiable’ advertising

Historically, advertising operated on a declarative model: ‘This is what we say about ourselves.’ The BuyTryShare model introduces a subtle but radical shift: ‘This is what our customers say — and here’s how you can verify it.’

This is not a break with creativity. It is an extension of its credibility: advertising continues to inspire dreams, evidence provides reassurance, and the media becomes the link between the two.

In summary

BuyTryShare does not incorporate reviews into advertising. It incorporates the ability to verify into the advertising itself. And in a world where mistrust has become a reflex, this simple shift — from isolated messages to verifiable messages — profoundly changes the nature of advertising effectiveness.

The real problem with traditional advertising revealed by this graph

It is no longer trusted by default. The most revealing figure in this graph is not Google’s 46% or the brand website’s 34%. It is the 4% attributed to advertising. Not because it ‘condemns’ advertising, but because it reveals a much deeper reality: advertising is no longer considered a credible source in itself.

  • It is not a crisis of creativity.

  • It is not a crisis of formats.

  • It is not even a crisis of audience.

  • It is a crisis of evidence.

Today, an advertising message is perceived as a claim by default. And every claim invites verification.

Today, an advertising message is perceived as a default assertion. And every assertion calls for verification.

This is precisely what explains a phenomenon that has been observed for several years in the United States — and is beginning to occur in Europe: the structural decline in TV advertising revenue, while Google, Meta, Amazon and TikTok capture most of the growth. Why is this?

Because platforms have long since incorporated what traditional advertising has ignored:

  • immediate access to evidence,

  • measurement of intent,

  • continuity between exposure and action.

Traditional media, meanwhile, remained stuck in a model where attention was supposed to be enough.

This graph puts an end to that illusion. It shows that without actionable proof, advertising is automatically bypassed. It may trigger an emotion… but it loses the battle for credibility.

And this is precisely where BuyTryShare provides an industrial solution.

Advertising must no longer just capture attention

It must inspire confidence. This graph does not call advertising into question. It simply reminds it that it must become relevant again. In 2025:

  • advertising is no longer a place of proof,

  • but it remains the key moment when the need for proof arises.

Certified reviews are not there to ‘look good’ in an advert: they are there to make the message verifiable, immediately, simply, without friction. BuyTryShare does not seek to change existing habits. It relies on an already established reflex: see → doubt → verify

The difference is that he:

  • anticipates this reflex,

  • organises it,

  • channels it,

  • and makes it measurable for brands and media alike.

We are entering an era in which:

  • All serious advertising will need to offer a path to validation,

  • any exposure without proof will be perceived as incomplete,

  • and media capable of monetising trust, not just attention, will regain the upper hand.

In this context, BuyTryShare is not an anomaly. It is a logical evolution. Because tomorrow’s advertising will not win by speaking louder. It will win by proving itself better.

In an age of mistrust, advertising will no longer win by promising more, but by providing access to proof.

Context, credibility, customer: the new golden triangle for brands in 2026

The context is no longer neutral: it becomes a signal.

In 2026, the environment in which an advertisement is displayed no longer plays a mere background role. It actively influences how the message is perceived. Context becomes a co-brand symbol: it either lends credibility to or undermines what you have to say.

In other words: the channel stamps its reputation on your message.

👉 When an advertisement is broadcast on television, shown in movie theaters, or published in the pages of a well-known daily newspaper, it benefits from an aura effect. The host media acts as a quality filter: it reassures viewers, lends credibility to the brand’s message, and increases the chances of engagement.

Conversely, distribution in a crowded social feed—between two pieces of UGC or alongside sensationalist videos—exposes the brand to dilution or even rejection. Even with relevant targeting, trust will not follow if the context does not support it.

This is a critical point in a market saturated with messages: it’s no longer just what you say that matters—it’s where you say it.

A visual broadcast on Canale 5 during the 8 p.m. news (TG5), a testimonial inserted in an insert in the New York Times, or a customer review shown before a movie in a UGC cinema, do not carry the same weight as a clip posted on Instagram or TikTok. The setting becomes implicit proof of reliability.

🎯 Conclusion: In 2026, brands must integrate a “context planning” approach in the same way as media planning or target planning. Because a good message in the wrong context becomes inaudible. Whereas a credible message in a respected context becomes proof.

A battle of confidence: traditional media outlets are holding out… but are in the crosshairs of GAFAM

In 2026, trust remains largely associated with regulated traditional media (television, press, cinema). According to the Kantar Media Reactions 2025 study, the media perceived as most trustworthy by consumers are still:

  • TV: 43% trust

  • Print media: 38%

  • Cinema: 35%

    … compared to only 21% for social media and 19% for UGC video platforms such as YouTube or TikTok.

💡 However, these bastions of credibility are under pressure. The partial or targeted acquisition of “premium” media assets by streaming platforms or GAFAM companies is proof of this.

For example:

  • Netflix is in exclusive negotiations to acquire Warner Bros Discovery’s “WBD Streaming & Studios” division in early 2027—including gems such as HBO, HBO Max, Warner Bros Pictures, New Line Cinema, TNT Sports, etc. This move would leave out linear channels such as CNN, Discovery, and Eurosport, which remain in the WBD Global Networks division. This type of split illustrates a dual phenomenon:

    1. Platforms want to capture the aura of historical quality (HBO, cinema) to fuel their own offerings.

    2. But they are leaving behind linear channels, which they consider less compatible with their model, even though they retain a strong foundation of trust.

  • Amazon’s acquisition of MGM (finalized in 2022 for $8.45 billion) sends a strong signal: digital giants are not only investing in technology and targeting. They are seeking to acquire the cultural credibility and narrative power of the major traditional studios.

    • MGM has more than 4,000 films and 17,000 episodes of series—a global cultural footprint (James Bond, Rocky, etc.) that is far more powerful than any series native to a platform.

    • As The Guardian analyzed, Amazon did not simply buy a catalog, but “access to Hollywood’s generational trust.”

➡️ This move confirms one thing: the perceived value of traditional media remains very strong—even among those who once disrupted it.

➡️ What this means for BuyTryShare: Even when under fire, traditional media remain a bastion of credibility. It is their association with certified customer reviews (post-purchase reviews, standardized boxes) that will enable them to reconcile media power with trust. And turn it into a strategic asset in the face of algorithmic invasion.

Context, credibility, customer: the new golden triangle for brands in 2026

For decades, brands occupied a central position in advertising narratives: they spoke, and the public listened (or not). But in 2026, this centrality shifted. It is no longer the brand’s intention that convinces, but rather the customer’s experience in a credible context.

Proof can no longer be decreed. It must be demonstrated.

A strong visual image, a reliable environment, an authentic voice: this is the new triptych of effectiveness. We no longer buy into promises. We adhere to proven results.

Customer testimonials move from reviews to advertising

Customer recommendations are no longer limited to product listings or Google reviews. They have become a strategic communication asset.

Concrete examples:

  • Automotive: a brand such as Audi could include a verified review from a recent buyer, certified according to ISO 20488, in its TV commercial.

    Cosmetics: in a press insert, a post-purchase customer testimonial would reinforce the message of naturalness or dermatological tolerance of a L’Oréal Men Expert skincare product.

  • Food industry: a 7-second movie ad shown before a Cinemaxx screening, where a real certified customer would simply say “I didn’t believe in plant-based yogurts… until I tried Alpro’s”.

In these three cases, advertising becomes shared evidence. And this evidence does not come from a slogan, but from real-life experience.

The brain encodes better when the source is perceived as reliable.

Neuroscience confirms this effect. According to a 2024 study by Neuro-Insight, an advertising message presented in a context deemed serious (reputable newspaper, news channel, movie theater) generates:

  • +23% activity in areas linked to long-term memory

  • +18% emotional resonance

  • A greater propensity to purchase if the source is perceived as “disinterested”

This means that the context influences not only how the message is received, but also how long it sticks. In other words, the same message will be better received if the media context inspires trust. This is something that social media no longer guarantees to

The customer becomes the proof—and the guarantee—of a sound investment.

For both marketing and finance departments, 2026 marks a turning point: every dollar invested must demonstrate its usefulness, not only in terms of visibility, but also in terms of credibility and real impact on brand preference.

But in a saturated, unstable, and sometimes toxic advertising environment, the most reliable signal is the one that comes from the customer themselves.

  • Not from a paid influencer.

  • Not from a targeting algorithm.

But from a real consumer, after purchase, who shares their validated feedback. This is precisely what BuyTryShare proposes to integrate into media campaigns:

✅ 1. Certified customer reviews, post-purchase

Collected in accordance with NF522 or ISO 20488 standards, they guarantee authenticity, the absence of excessive inducement, and traceability. This provides legal and reputational assurance, reassuring for CMOs and validatable internally by Compliance.

✅ 2. Distribution in premium environments

TV, press, cinema: regulated media with a stable editorial framework, where brand safety is native—no configuration required.

This secures the distribution context and backs up customer proof with a trusted channel. It is the combination of “strong media + credible message.”

✅ 3. An agile, short format, without costly redesign of assets

The BuyTryShare format is added as an appendix, in 5 seconds. It can be integrated into an existing campaign without requiring a complete re-edit or complex production.

It’s a low-cost, high-impact investment — ideal for testing, learning, and optimizing.

What this means for a CMO:

  • You no longer depend solely on reach or brand storytelling.

  • You add a signal of truth to your campaigns.

  • And you create a differentiating asset in an advertising world where everything looks the same..

What this means for a CFO:

Media spending is no longer an “intangible” line item. It can now be measured in terms of perceived evidence. It adds credibility to an existing message without increasing budgets or risks. It’s a good way to boost the emotional profitability of a media plan.

🎯 In summary: BuyTryShare offers visible, standardized, integrable, and cost-effective customer proof.

And in a world where trust is rare, this proof becomes a decisive competitive advantage.

Customer centricity: when brands talk about listening to customers… without really listening to their customers

The paradox of customer centricity

Brands love to proclaim their love for their customers: slogans, value statements, promises of a ‘human-centred’ experience. They want to be ‘customer-centric’, at the heart of their discourse and strategy.

However, once we take the step of giving real customers a direct voice — through their recommendations, opinions and public statements — our reflexes change: moderation, filtering, control, selection of ‘clean’ cases.

This discrepancy between rhetoric (“the customer is king”) and reality (I control what the customer should say or not say, according to my own terms) undermines brand credibility in an era of proof of use and transparency.

It is this paradox that we will explore: why so many brands are willing to invest in influencers — but hesitate to activate their actual customers.

What the numbers say

Here are some figures, gleaned from available studies, which shed light on this behaviour.

  • In the automotive sector, a study by the Reputation agency indicates that 56% of European consumers say they ‘consult reviews and/or social media for major purchases such as a car’.

  • Another source (industry blog) mentions that ‘over 90% of car buyers consult online reviews when purchasing a car.’

  • On influencer marketing:

    • 69% of consumers say they trust recommendations from a friend or influencer more than those from a brand itself. (source)

    • A study indicates that only 37% of consumers trust influencers ‘more than the brand’.

    • Others show that, in reality, confidence is declining: in the “Influencer Trust Index”, only 74% trust or somewhat trust influencer content, compared to 87% for traditional advertising in the United States.

  • Regarding the use of paid influencers: the influencer marketing industry is growing rapidly, which shows that brands are very active in this area (source)

Summary of lessons learned:

  • For major purchases (such as cars), consulting third-party reviews/testimonials has become virtually essential (>50%, often >90%).

  • Brands have long known that social proof (reviews, recommendations) carries significant weight in purchasing decisions.

  • Paradoxically, brands are much more inclined to hire paid influencers than to openly activate real, unpaid customers as spokespersons.

  • This indicates a gap between ‘we say we listen to the customer’ and ‘we let the customer speak freely/publicly’.

The automotive sector: an industry obsessed with image

Let us take the example of the automotive sector, a very large investor in advertising worldwide.

  • Brands invest millions in customer experience, design, and premium service (for premium and luxury brands).

  • However, when we look at their customer advocacy policy, we often notice: selected video testimonials, no paid media, few public forums, customers moderated by the brand, and little promotion of “ordinary” customers.

  • But data shows that buyers seek out these reviews: over 90% read reviews before making a purchase (or even ‘over 90%’ according to Embedsocial).

  • What this suggests: while customers are willing to give their opinions and seek them out, brands may be reluctant to open this channel publicly because it exposes them to potentially negative feedback and a loss of control over the narrative. Put simply, they (often) lack the structure to make the most of it.

Implications:

  • A brand that says ‘the customer is at the heart’ but does not allow that customer to be visible or speak freely may appear inauthentic.

  • In the premium/luxury sector, where image is key, the temptation to ‘control’ even more is strong — and this conflicts with the unfiltered social proof that customers are looking for.

What the United States reveals: same dynamics, same effects

In the United States, the use of influencers is even more common:

  • 63% of consumers say they are more likely to purchase a product recommended by an influencer than a product that is not recommended. (source)

  • However, when it comes to trust, only 5% of consumers say they ‘completely trust’ influencer content. (source)

  • This creates a double standard: brands invest, but the quality of trust is uncertain. Conversely, it is customer reviews (unpaid, freely given) that are often perceived as more reliable.

Thus, the tension is widespread: talking about being “customer-centric” is one thing, but allowing customers to participate in the conversation (and sometimes criticise) is another.

BuyTryShare: reconnecting promises and proof

It is in this middle ground, between the brand that speaks and the customer who takes a back seat, that the opportunity lies:

  • give real customers the opportunity to become certified ambassadors (not paid influencers, but authentic users);

  • integrate their proof of use and testimonials into media channels (TV, press, cinema and digital) in a transparent manner;

  • enable the brand to maintain media consistency and legal compliance, while giving the microphone to real experiences.

With this approach, the brand moves from simple ‘customer-centric talk’ to genuine ‘customer-proof action’. It aligns:

  • Promise (the customer is at the heart)

  • Proof (the customer speaks freely, visibly)

  • Delivery (the brand uses this authentic voice across its channels).

The media showcase: preserving creativity, enhancing evidence

Television, cinema and print media remain the most powerful platforms for enhancing an advertising message. Their emotional impact and production quality should not be compromised by functional or informative elements such as ratings or reviews.

That is why, in the BuyTryShare system, customer proof never interferes with the original creation. The review, rating and call-to-action (QR code, link, etc.) are displayed in a separate message, immediately adjacent to the advertisement, with a dedicated background and format designed and approved by the brand and its agency.

Thus, the creative signature remains intact, while authentic proof is expressed in a complementary, harmonious and certified space.

The media retains all its nobility, the brand all its mastery, and the consumer, finally, their voice.

Conclusion

The mantra ‘the customer is our priority’ is ubiquitous — but many brands want customers to remain visible only if they remain moderate, aligned and controlled.

However, the figures are clear: buyers (whether of cars or other products) seek out, consult and trust testimonials from real customers much more than carefully crafted brand messaging or overpriced influencers.

The real challenge for premium brands today is not simply to pay an “influencer” to talk about them, but to reveal and promote their customers — and to give themselves the means to manage this voice with sincerity, structure and transparency.